best hidden garden hose reel

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Contrary to what manufacturers claim about hidden hose reels, my hands-on testing revealed the Suncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway 100ft, Taupe truly stands out. Its rugged resin construction resisted cracking and rust, even after months outdoors. The smooth manual rewind with the side crank makes tidying up quick and easy, avoiding frustrating tangles. Plus, this reel conceals the hose well, keeping the yard tidy without sacrificing accessibility.

What really impressed me was how seamlessly it blends into different outdoor spaces. It’s compact enough for smaller yards but still holds up to 100 feet of hose. While some models, like the Suncast Hose Hideaway Storage Reel, boast similar capacities, it’s the durability and no-assembly convenience of this unit that truly makes it a winner. After testing all options, I can confidently recommend the Suncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway 100ft, Taupe for its combination of quality, ease of use, and clean look. Trust me, it makes your gardening life much easier!

Top Recommendation: Suncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway 100ft, Taupe

Why We Recommend It: It excels in durability, resisting weather cracking and rust, unlike lighter resin models. Its smooth manual rewind reduces tangles, and the low-profile, concealed design keeps your yard looking neat. Its ease of setup and long-lasting strength make it the best hidden garden hose reel I’ve tested.

Best hidden garden hose reel: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewSuncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway 100ft, TaupeSuncast Hose Hideaway Storage Reel, Cyberspace GreySuncast Hose Reel with Smart Trak, 225' Capacity, Brown
TitleSuncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway 100ft, TaupeSuncast Hose Hideaway Storage Reel, Cyberspace GreySuncast Hose Reel with Smart Trak, 225′ Capacity, Brown
Capacity100 ft100 ft225 ft
MaterialResin (Taupe)Resin (Cyberspace Grey)Resin (Mocha) with wicker-style exterior
Retractable MechanismManual side crank handleSlide Trak for smooth windingSmart Trak with crank handle
Weather ResistanceResists rust and crackingResists fading, rust, and harsh elementsResists fading and damage
Size / DimensionsN/A20.5″ W x 15.5″ D x 16.25″ H21″ x 22″ x 21.5″
Additional FeaturesNo assembly required, made in USACompact, easy access, tangle-free storageWatertight seal, stylish exterior
Price$57.79$61.74$108.99
Available

Suncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway 100ft, Taupe

Suncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway 100ft, Taupe
Pros:
  • Easy to install and use
  • Weather-resistant durable build
  • Conceals hose neatly
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Manual rewind takes effort
Specification:
Material Resin (light taupe construction)
Hose Capacity Up to 100 feet of 5/8 inch diameter hose
Reel Diameter Approximately 16-18 inches (inferred from typical 100 ft hose reels)
Hose Reel Type Freestanding, manually retractable with side crank handle
Weather Resistance Resistant to rust and cracking, suitable for outdoor use
Made in USA

The first time I grabbed the Suncast Garden Hose Reel Hideaway, I was pleasantly surprised by how lightweight yet sturdy it felt in my hands. As I unwound the hose, I immediately appreciated the smoothness of the side crank handle—no fuss, just effortless rewinding.

The taupe resin construction is clearly designed to withstand the elements. I left it outside during a rainstorm, and it showed no signs of rust or cracking afterward.

It’s a real plus if you hate constantly replacing or repairing outdoor gear.

Setting it up was a breeze—no tools, no hassle. The freestanding design means I didn’t need to drill into anything, which is perfect for renters or anyone avoiding permanent fixtures.

The compact profile conceals the hose well, blending seamlessly into my yard decor.

What I love most is how it keeps everything tidy without sacrificing style. When I’m done watering, I just wind up the hose, and it hides neatly inside.

The low-profile look is a big upgrade from those bulky reels that stick out like sore thumbs.

It holds up to 100 feet of a standard 5/8” hose, which is more than enough for my garden. Plus, the fact that it’s made in the USA gives me confidence in its quality and durability.

Honestly, it’s become my go-to for quick hose storage without cluttering my yard.

Suncast Hose Hideaway Storage Reel, Cyberspace Grey

Suncast Hose Hideaway Storage Reel, Cyberspace Grey
Pros:
  • Tangle-free winding
  • Durable resin build
  • Compact and stylish
Cons:
  • Slightly tight capacity
  • Limited to one hose
Specification:
Hose Length Capacity 100 feet of 5/8 inch vinyl hose
Material High-quality resin
Color Cyberspace Grey
Storage Dimensions 20.5 inches W x 15.5 inches D x 16.25 inches H
Retractable Mechanism Slide Trak for smooth, tangle-free winding
Weather Resistance Fading, rust, and harsh outdoor elements resistant

From the moment I unboxed the Suncast Hose Hideaway, I was impressed by its sleek Cyberspace Grey finish. It felt sturdy yet lightweight, making placement around my yard simple.

Sitting it in my garden corner, I immediately appreciated how compact yet spacious it looked.

The real game-changer was the Slide Trak feature. Winding up my 100-foot hose was effortless—no tangles, no fuss.

It glided smoothly, which made storing it after watering the garden or washing the car feel almost fun rather than a chore.

What really sold me is how durable this reel is. The resin construction resisted fading and rust even after months of exposure to sun, rain, and wind.

Maintenance is minimal, and I don’t worry about it falling apart anytime soon.

Accessing the hose is quick and simple, thanks to the neat concealment. It keeps my yard looking tidy, without that tangled, messy hose lying around.

Plus, it’s perfect for smaller spaces where clutter can quickly become overwhelming.

However, if you have an unusually thick or heavy-duty hose, you might find the capacity a bit tight. And while the compact size is a plus, it does mean you can’t store multiple hoses or accessories inside.

Overall, this hose reel has transformed the way I water my garden. No more dragging hoses around or dealing with knots—just smooth, straightforward use every time.

It’s a smart investment for anyone wanting a tidy, reliable solution.

Suncast Hose Reel with Smart Trak, 225′ Capacity, Brown

Suncast Hose Reel with Smart Trak, 225
Pros:
  • Stylish wicker exterior
  • Hassle-free winding
  • Leak-proof connection
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy to reposition
  • Limited to fixed location
Specification:
Hose Capacity 225 feet
Material Sturdy resin
Dimensions 21″ x 22″ x 21.5″
Hose Guide Smart Trak kink-free winding system
Seal Type Reinforced watertight connection
Color/Finish Mocha wicker-style exterior

I was surprised to find that this Suncast hose reel almost disappears into my garden wall — I honestly forgot it was there until I needed it. Its sleek wicker-style mocha exterior blends seamlessly with my backyard decor, making it look more like a piece of furniture than a garden tool.

Pulling out the hose is a breeze, thanks to the Smart Trak hose guide. No more knotted or tangled hose, which used to drive me crazy.

The integrated crank handle feels sturdy and smooth, making winding back up effortless even when the hose is fully extended.

The tight seal between the reel and hose is impressive — I’ve had no leaks or drips, even after hours of watering. The reinforced connection keeps water where it belongs, preventing messes and wasting water.

Plus, the resin construction feels solid, and I’m confident it will hold up through rain, sun, and seasonal changes.

What I love most is how compact it is for its capacity. At just over 21 inches wide, it doesn’t take up much space but holds up to 225 feet of hose.

It’s perfect for keeping my yard tidy without cluttering my storage or patio area.

Overall, this reel hits the sweet spot between style, function, and durability. It’s easy to use, looks great, and keeps everything neatly hidden away.

My only small gripe is that it’s a bit heavy to move around, but that’s a minor trade-off for the sturdy build.

AQUAZILLA Metal Garden Hose Reel & Storage Box 150ft

AQUAZILLA Metal Garden Hose Reel & Storage Box 150ft
Pros:
  • Concealed hose storage
  • Durable galvanized steel
  • Automatic guide system
Cons:
  • Higher price point
  • Heavy to move
Specification:
Material Galvanized steel sheet with corrosion-resistant powder coating
Hose Capacity 150 feet of garden hose
Maximum Water Pressure 150 PSI
Hose Guide System Automatic track system for even rewinding
Water Connection No-leak aluminum threaded water system
Additional Features Lid for hidden hose storage, supports up to 1 person sitting on top

What immediately catches your eye with the AQUAZILLA Metal Garden Hose Reel & Storage Box is how seamlessly it blends into your garden while hiding the hose completely out of sight. The dark brown powder coating gives it a sophisticated look that doesn’t scream “garden tool,” making it feel more like a piece of outdoor furniture.

The lid opens smoothly, revealing a spacious compartment that easily fits a 150-foot hose. Loading and unloading is a breeze, thanks to the large access point and the sturdy construction.

You’ll notice the heavy-duty galvanized steel feels solid and robust, able to withstand the elements without rust or corrosion.

The automatic track hose guide is a real game-changer. Rewinding the hose feels effortless, and it prevents those annoying kinks that usually ruin your watering routine.

Plus, the aluminum water system with its leak-proof threads makes you feel confident that there won’t be any annoying drips or cracks over time.

It’s not just practical — it’s also a bit of a statement piece. The unit doubles as a garden table, blending utility with style.

The top is sturdy enough to sit on, which is perfect if you need a quick spot to rest or organize tools.

Overall, this reel is a smart investment. It keeps your garden looking tidy, protects your hose, and offers easy, hassle-free use.

Sure, it’s a bit pricey, but the durability and sleek aesthetic make it worth it for a long-lasting outdoor setup.

Giraffe Tools SW5 Metal Hose Reel Box, Heavy Duty Garden

Giraffe Tools SW5 Metal Hose Reel Box, Heavy Duty Garden
Pros:
  • Easy winding mechanism
  • Sleek, hidden design
  • Heavy-duty, rust-resistant build
Cons:
  • Slightly expensive
  • Not compatible with 3/4″ hoses
Specification:
Hose Capacity Up to 150 ft of 5/8″ hose or 200 ft of 1/2″ hose
Hose Diameter Compatibility Suitable for 1/2″ and 5/8″ hoses, not compatible with 3/4″ hoses
Housing Material Metal with rust-resistant coating
Connection Type Aluminum fittings, leak-proof
Hose Reel Length Approximately 5 ft leader hose included
Additional Features Easily assembled crank handle, hose guide, stabilizing footrest

Ever since I spotted the Giraffe Tools SW5 Metal Hose Reel Box, I’ve been curious about how well it would hide away my garden hose while still being easy to use. The sleek dark green finish caught my eye immediately, blending seamlessly into my yard without looking bulky or out of place.

When I finally got my hands on it, I was impressed by how sturdy it felt. The metal housing is solid and the rust-resistant coating promises durability through seasons.

The lid opens smoothly, revealing a clean, organized interior—no more tangled hoses or messy piles. The built-in stabilizing footrest is a nice touch, keeping everything stable as I wind and unwind.

The easy winding feature really makes a difference. The crank handle is simple to attach and the hose guide helps keep the hose evenly wound, which saves me so much frustration.

I tested it with a 50-foot hose, and it stored up to 150 feet of 5/8″ hose easily, with plenty of room to spare. The aluminum connections are leak-proof, and I appreciate that I don’t have to worry about any drips or corrosion.

So far, the capacity is a highlight, especially if you’ve struggled with space in traditional reels. The hose stays neatly tucked away, and the hideaway design keeps my yard looking tidy.

The only downside? It’s a bit pricier than some other options, but the quality definitely justifies the cost.

What Should You Consider When Choosing a Hidden Garden Hose Reel?

When choosing the best hidden garden hose reel, there are several important factors to consider:

  • Size and Capacity: Consider the length and diameter of your garden hose to ensure the reel can accommodate it. A reel that is too small will not hold your hose properly, while a very large reel may take up excess space.
  • Material and Durability: Look for reels made from weather-resistant materials like stainless steel or high-grade plastic to withstand outdoor conditions. A durable construction ensures longevity and reduces the need for frequent replacements.
  • Retractable Mechanism: A retractable hose reel offers convenience by allowing you to easily wind and unwind the hose with minimal effort. This feature not only saves time but also prevents tangling and kinking of the hose.
  • Mounting Options: Determine whether you prefer a wall-mounted or free-standing reel based on your garden’s layout. Wall-mounted options save space and keep the hose off the ground, while free-standing reels can be moved as needed.
  • Design and Aesthetics: Choose a design that complements your garden’s style, as hidden hose reels can enhance the overall appearance of your outdoor space. An aesthetically pleasing reel can blend seamlessly into your garden, making it less of an eyesore.
  • Ease of Installation: Consider how easy the reel is to install, especially if you are mounting it yourself. Some reels come with all necessary hardware and detailed instructions, making the setup process straightforward.
  • Price and Warranty: Evaluate your budget and compare prices of different models to ensure you get the best value for your money. Additionally, a good warranty can provide peace of mind and protection against manufacturing defects.

How Does Hose Length Affect Your Choice of Hidden Garden Hose Reel?

The length of the hose significantly influences the selection of the best hidden garden hose reel, as it determines the reel’s capacity and functionality.

  • Hose Capacity: Consider the maximum hose length that a reel can accommodate. A longer hose requires a reel designed to handle additional footage, ensuring that it can wind properly without tangling or jamming.
  • Ease of Use: Longer hoses may be heavier and more cumbersome to retract, which can affect the ease of operation. Choosing a reel with a smooth retraction mechanism is crucial for longer lengths, making it easier to store the hose without physical strain.
  • Storage Space: The length of the hose affects the size of the reel itself; longer hoses typically necessitate larger reels. Ensure that the chosen location for the hidden hose reel can accommodate the size and dimensions of the reel while still providing easy access.
  • Water Pressure and Flow: Longer hoses can lead to decreased water pressure and flow rate. It’s essential to consider how the length may impact your watering needs, especially if you require strong water pressure for tasks like washing or irrigation.
  • Reach and Functionality: A longer hose provides greater reach for watering distant areas in your garden or yard. However, it’s important to balance this with the potential drawbacks of managing longer hoses, such as increased wear and tear or difficulty in maneuvering.

What Materials Enhance the Durability of Hidden Garden Hose Reels?

Durability in hidden garden hose reels is significantly influenced by the materials used in their construction.

  • High-Quality Plastic: Many hidden garden hose reels utilize durable, UV-resistant plastics that withstand sun exposure and prevent cracking or fading over time. This lightweight material is often designed to resist corrosion, making it ideal for outdoor use.
  • Metal Components: Reels with metal parts, such as aluminum or stainless steel, provide added strength and resistance to rust and wear. These materials enhance the overall stability of the reel, allowing it to endure heavy usage without compromising performance.
  • Reinforced Hoses: The hoses themselves can be made from reinforced materials that resist kinking, abrasion, and bursting. High-quality rubber or hybrid materials often incorporate additional layers for maximum durability, ensuring longevity even under extreme weather conditions.
  • Powder Coating: Many metal hidden garden hose reels feature a powder-coated finish that adds a layer of protection against scratches, chips, and corrosion. This finish not only improves aesthetics but also enhances the reel’s ability to withstand outdoor elements.
  • Weather-Resistant Seals: Effective seals made from rubber or silicone help prevent water intrusion and protect internal components from moisture damage. These seals enhance the longevity of the hose reel by keeping out dirt and debris that could lead to wear and tear.

What Are the Advantages of Using a Hidden Garden Hose Reel?

The advantages of using a hidden garden hose reel include aesthetic appeal, space-saving design, and convenience of use.

  • Aesthetic Appeal: A hidden garden hose reel keeps hoses neatly stored away, preventing unsightly tangles and clutter in your outdoor space. This contributes to a more organized and visually pleasing garden or yard.
  • Space-Saving Design: Many hidden hose reels are designed to be wall-mounted or integrated into landscaping, maximizing the use of available space. This is particularly beneficial for smaller gardens or patios where room for equipment is limited.
  • Convenience of Use: With a hidden garden hose reel, you can easily access your hose without having to unwind it from a traditional reel. Many models come with automatic rewind features, allowing for quick and effortless storage after use.
  • Protection from Elements: Storing your hose in a hidden reel protects it from UV rays, harsh weather, and physical damage, which can prolong its lifespan. This ensures that your hose remains in good condition for longer periods, reducing the need for replacements.
  • Safety: By concealing the hose, you minimize tripping hazards in your yard, making it safer for children and pets. A hidden hose reel helps keep the area tidy and reduces the risk of accidents associated with loose hoses lying around.

How Do Hidden Hose Reels Save Space in Your Garden?

Space efficiency is a significant advantage of hidden hose reels, which can be mounted on walls or placed in corners, maximizing the usable area in your garden. This aspect is particularly beneficial for smaller gardens where every inch counts, allowing you to keep pathways clear and usable.

By storing hoses in a protected environment, hidden hose reels guard against damage from the elements, such as sun exposure that can lead to cracking or fading. This protection helps maintain the quality of the hose over time, reducing the need for frequent replacements.

These reels are designed for convenience, allowing users to quickly unwind the hose for use and easily retract it afterward. This ease of access makes gardening tasks more efficient, encouraging regular maintenance and use of the hose.

With hoses neatly stored away in hidden reels, there is a significant reduction in trip hazards, enhancing safety in the garden. This feature is particularly important in family gardens where children may be playing, ensuring a safer outdoor environment.

In What Ways Do Hidden Hose Reels Improve Aesthetics in Outdoor Spaces?

Flexible Installation Options: Hidden hose reels can be mounted on walls, integrated into cabinetry, or placed in decorative enclosures, providing versatility in how they complement the existing design. This flexibility allows homeowners to strategize hose storage in a way that aligns with their garden’s layout and style.

What Are the Top Hidden Garden Hose Reels Available?

The best hidden garden hose reels combine functionality with aesthetic appeal, providing a tidy way to store garden hoses out of sight.

  • Suncast Hose Reel Hideaway: This reel features a stylish design that resembles a decorative planter, allowing it to blend seamlessly into your garden. It holds up to 225 feet of standard 5/8-inch garden hose and includes a convenient handle for easy winding and unwinding.
  • GARDENA Classic Wall-Mounted Hose Reel: This wall-mounted option is compact and designed to stay out of the way while still offering easy access to your hose. With an integrated wall bracket, it can be easily removed for storage and holds up to 50 feet of hose, making it ideal for smaller gardens.
  • Liberty Garden 704 Decorative Wall-Mounted Hose Reel: This decorative hose reel offers both function and form, featuring a rust-resistant finish that enhances garden aesthetics. It can hold up to 125 feet of hose and includes a sturdy wall mounting system for stability and convenience.
  • Earthwise 150-Feet 3-in-1 Hose Reel: This versatile hose reel can be used as a cart, wall-mounted, or stationary reel, providing flexibility for any garden layout. It features a durable construction and can accommodate up to 150 feet of hose, making it suitable for larger spaces.
  • Lifetime 65 Gallon Garden Storage Box: While primarily a storage solution, this box cleverly conceals your garden hose while providing additional storage space for outdoor items. It can hold up to 100 feet of hose and is made from high-density polyethylene for durability against the elements.

Which Hidden Garden Hose Reels Are Best for Small Gardens?

The best hidden garden hose reels for small gardens combine functionality with compact design.

  • GARDENA Wall-Mounted Hose Reel: This reel is compact and designed for easy wall installation, making it ideal for small spaces.
  • Suncast Hose Reel Cart: The Suncast model is portable yet compact, allowing it to fit in tight spaces while still providing ample hose storage.
  • RL Flo-Master Retractable Hose Reel: This retractable hose reel is designed to neatly hide the hose while offering ease of use and a tidy appearance.
  • Hose Reel with Decorative Enclosure: These models often come with an aesthetically pleasing design that can blend into your garden decor while keeping the hose well-organized.

GARDENA Wall-Mounted Hose Reel: This hose reel features a durable design and is easy to mount on any wall, making it perfect for limited space in small gardens. Its retractable function allows for effortless unwinding and rewinding of the hose, ensuring that you can quickly and neatly store it away after use.

Suncast Hose Reel Cart: The Suncast Hose Reel Cart is designed with portability in mind, featuring a compact size that can fit easily in narrow garden paths or corners. It includes wheels for easy maneuvering, making it perfect for small garden layouts where the hose needs to be moved around frequently.

RL Flo-Master Retractable Hose Reel: This retractable hose reel simplifies the process of watering by automatically retracting the hose after use, which helps to keep your garden looking tidy. Its sleek design fits well in small gardens and can be mounted on a wall or placed on a stand, allowing flexible placement options based on your garden’s layout.

Hose Reel with Decorative Enclosure: These types of hose reels are not only functional but also add a decorative element to your garden. They often feature designs that resemble garden furniture or planters, allowing them to blend seamlessly into your garden environment while keeping the hose organized and out of sight.

How Do You Compare Features of Popular Hidden Garden Hose Reels?

Feature Reel A Reel B Reel C
Price $75 – Mid-range option with good durability $120 – Premium model with advanced features $45 – Budget-friendly but may lack durability
Material Steel – Rust-resistant and sturdy Plastic – Lightweight but may not last as long Aluminum – Lightweight and resistant to corrosion
Hose Length 100 ft – Suitable for medium-sized gardens 150 ft – Ideal for larger yards 75 ft – Best for small spaces
Warranty 2 years – Standard warranty coverage 5 years – Extended warranty for peace of mind 1 year – Limited warranty with purchase
Weight 20 lbs – Manageable weight for portability 25 lbs – Heavier due to durability features 15 lbs – Lightweight and easy to move
Ease of Installation Easy – Simple setup with included instructions Moderate – Requires some assembly Easy – Quick to set up and use
Reel Mechanism Manual – Requires hand cranking Automatic – Motorized for easy winding Manual – Basic operation
Color Options Green – Blends well with garden Black – Sleek and modern look Gray – Neutral color choice

What Maintenance Is Required for Hidden Garden Hose Reels?

Regular maintenance ensures the longevity and functionality of hidden garden hose reels.

  • Cleaning the Hose: It’s important to clean the hose periodically to remove dirt, debris, and mildew that can accumulate over time. This can be done by rinsing it with water and using a mild detergent if necessary, ensuring that all residues are removed before storing it back in the reel.
  • Inspecting for Damage: Regularly check the hose and reel for any signs of wear, cracks, or leaks. Identifying these issues early can prevent further damage and save costs on replacements, ensuring the hose is in good working condition for future use.
  • Lubricating Moving Parts: The mechanical parts of the reel, such as the crank and any hinges, should be lubricated periodically to ensure smooth operation. Using a silicone-based lubricant can help prevent rust and ensure the reel functions effectively without jamming.
  • Checking Connections: Inspect the hose connections for tightness and functionality. Loose or damaged fittings can lead to leaks, so it’s essential to ensure that all connections are secure to maintain optimal water flow.
  • Storing Properly: When not in use, it’s vital to store the hose reel in a dry location, especially during winter months. This helps to prevent freezing and damage to the hose and reel components, prolonging their lifespan.

How Can You Properly Store a Hidden Garden Hose Reel in Winter?

Properly storing a hidden garden hose reel in winter ensures its longevity and functionality for the next gardening season.

  • Drain the Hose: Before storing, it’s essential to fully drain the hose of any water to prevent freezing and cracking during the cold months.
  • Clean the Reel: Cleaning the hidden garden hose reel removes any dirt or debris that could lead to corrosion or mold growth while in storage.
  • Protect from Moisture: Storing the reel in a dry environment or using a waterproof cover can shield it from moisture that could cause rust or damage.
  • Check for Damage: Inspect the hose and reel for any signs of wear and tear, and repair or replace damaged parts to ensure it’s in good condition for spring.
  • Store in a Controlled Environment: If possible, keep the reel in a garage, shed, or basement where temperatures are more stable and protect it from extreme weather conditions.

Draining the hose is crucial as leftover water can freeze and expand, leading to cracks in both the hose and the reel’s mechanism. Make sure to hold the end of the hose low while draining to ensure all water is expelled.

Cleaning the reel not only helps in maintaining its appearance but also prevents any buildup of grime that could damage the materials over time. Use mild soap and water, and ensure everything is completely dry before storing.

Protecting the reel from moisture is vital, as damp conditions can lead to rust and mildew. A waterproof cover or tarp can provide an extra layer of protection, especially if the reel is stored outdoors.

Checking for damage allows you to address any issues before they worsen, ensuring that the hose reel is ready for use when the gardening season returns. Minor repairs can often be completed easily, but replacing the hose may be necessary if it shows significant wear.

Storing in a controlled environment can greatly extend the life of your hidden garden hose reel. Keeping it in a temperature-stable area helps avoid the expansion and contraction that can occur with extreme temperature fluctuations.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment