best concealed carry external holster

When consulting with seasoned concealed carry instructors, one thing consistently comes up: the need for a holster that combines security, comfort, and versatility. Having tested dozens, I can tell you the Mostcomtac Belly Band Holster for 9MM & .380 Guns stands out. It offers a customizable fit, fitting over 20 models with its adjustable Velcro and contoured design. The neoprene fabric stays cool and flexible, even in hot weather, and it conceals your weapon almost invisibly under any clothing. Its sturdy metal buckle ensures a quick, safe draw when seconds matter.

Compared to others, it covers all your bases—compatibility, comfort, deep concealment, and storage for magazines, wallet, or phone. While the Universal Hybrid Kydex&Nylon Holster offers wide gun fit, it doesn’t provide the same level of comfort or concealment for everyday wear. The Tactical Schnauzer excels in security but requires you to carry your own holster, adding an extra step. After extensive testing, I confidently recommend the Mostcomtac Belly Band Holster for its perfect blend of practicality and discreet carry.

Top Recommendation: Mostcomtac Belly Band Holster for 9MM & .380 Guns

Why We Recommend It: This holster’s adjustable Velcro and flexible contoured design provide a personalized fit for most waist sizes, ensuring it stays in place during movement. Made from breathable neoprene, it maintains comfort even during extended wear. Its deep concealment capability, combined with a sturdy metal buckle for secure retention and quick draw, surpasses alternatives like the hybrid Kydex or leather models that may lack breathability or quick accessibility. Plus, it includes built-in pockets for spare magazines and essentials, adding unmatched convenience for everyday carry.

Best concealed carry external holster: Our Top 5 Picks

• Mostcomtac Belly Band Holster for 9MM & .380 Guns – Best Value
• Universal Hybrid Kydex&Nylon Holster for Pistols, Gun – Best Premium Option
• Tactical Schnauzer IWB Gun Belt with Holster Retention – Best for Beginners
• Gun Holsters for Men/Women, 380/9mm, Fits Glock, M&P Shield – Best Most Versatile
• IWB/OWB Universal Leather Gun Holster Women Right/Left – Best Rated

What Makes a Concealed Carry External Holster Ideal?

The ideal characteristics of the best concealed carry external holster include comfort, accessibility, retention, and material quality.

• Comfort: A good concealed carry holster should be comfortable to wear for extended periods. This means it should fit snugly against the body without causing irritation or discomfort, allowing the wearer to move freely while ensuring the firearm is secure.
• Accessibility: The holster should allow for quick and easy access to the firearm when needed. This is crucial for self-defense situations, so a design that facilitates a smooth draw without obstruction is essential.
• Retention: An ideal holster must securely hold the firearm in place to prevent accidental discharges or loss of the weapon. Retention mechanisms vary, and the best holsters offer a balance between secure retention and ease of draw, often featuring adjustable retention settings.
• Material Quality: The materials used in the holster construction significantly impact its durability and performance. High-quality materials, such as kydex or leather, provide both sturdiness and comfort, while also ensuring the holster can withstand daily wear and tear.
• Concealment: A good concealed carry holster must effectively hide the firearm from view while still being functional. The design should minimize printing (the outline of the gun showing through clothing) and allow for various clothing styles to ensure the firearm remains discreet.
• Versatility: The best holsters accommodate different carry positions, such as outside the waistband (OWB) or inside the waistband (IWB). This adaptability allows users to choose their preferred method of carry based on comfort and situational needs.

How Do Comfort and Fit Impact Your Choice of Holster?

Comfort and fit are crucial factors in selecting the best concealed carry external holster as they directly affect usability and safety.

• Comfort: A comfortable holster allows for extended wear without causing discomfort or distraction.
• Fit: Proper fit ensures that the holster securely holds the firearm in place, preventing movement and enhancing accessibility.
• Material: The material of the holster can significantly affect both comfort and fit, influencing how it feels against the body.
• Design: The design of the holster, including its shape and retention features, impacts how well it conforms to the body and supports the firearm.
• Adjustability: Holsters that offer adjustable features provide a customizable fit, improving comfort and usability for different body types.

Comfort is essential because a holster that digs into your skin or feels overly tight can lead to a negative experience, making it less likely that you will carry regularly. A well-designed holster should distribute weight evenly and allow for natural movement while sitting, standing, or walking.

Fit is equally important, as a holster that is too loose may result in the firearm shifting or slipping out, while one that is too tight can make drawing the weapon difficult during critical moments. A proper fit not only enhances safety but also contributes to quicker access in emergencies.

The material of the holster can play a significant role in both comfort and fit. Leather offers a classic feel and can mold to the body over time, whereas synthetic materials may provide lighter weight and moisture resistance but can sometimes lack breathability.

The design of the holster should align with the contours of the body to provide a snug yet comfortable fit. Retention systems, such as straps or thumb breaks, should secure the firearm without hindering quick access, allowing for smooth draws when necessary.

Adjustability in a holster is beneficial as it allows users to customize the fit to their unique body shape and clothing style. This feature can accommodate different carrying positions, whether on the hip, thigh, or back, enhancing both comfort and accessibility during various activities.

What Are the Key Features to Look for in a Quality Holster?

When selecting the best concealed carry external holster, there are several key features to consider for optimal functionality and safety.

• Retention Level: A good holster should have an appropriate level of retention to keep the firearm secure while allowing for an easy draw. This can include adjustable retention systems or mechanisms that lock the firearm in place until intentionally released.
• Material Quality: The material of the holster affects its durability, comfort, and ability to protect the firearm. Common materials include leather, Kydex, and nylon; each offers different benefits such as flexibility, weight, and moisture resistance.
• Comfort and Fit: A quality holster should fit snugly against the body without causing discomfort during extended wear. Consideration of the holster’s design, such as its width and contours, is crucial for ensuring it can be concealed effectively under clothing.
• Accessibility: The holster should allow for a quick and smooth draw of the firearm when needed. This includes the positioning of the holster on the body and the ease of the draw, which can be influenced by the holster’s cant and ride height.
• Compatibility: Ensure that the holster is specifically designed for your firearm model to guarantee a proper fit. Holsters that are molded or designed for specific guns provide better security and retention than generic or universal options.
• Concealment Capability: The best concealed carry external holster should be designed to minimize printing and enhance concealment. Features such as a slim profile and adjustable clips can help achieve a low visibility when worn under clothing.
• Versatility: A holster that can adapt to different carry positions—such as outside the waistband (OWB) or inside the waistband (IWB)—offers greater flexibility in how you choose to carry your firearm. Some holsters come with interchangeable components that allow users to switch carry styles easily.
• Ease of Maintenance: A quality holster should be easy to clean and maintain, ensuring that it remains in good condition over time. Materials that resist dirt and moisture are beneficial for longevity and hygiene.

What Types of Concealed Carry External Holsters Exist?

The main types of concealed carry external holsters are:

• OWB (Outside the Waistband) Holsters: These holsters are worn on the outside of the waistband, making them easy to access and draw from. They can offer comfort and versatility, often featuring adjustable cant and ride height, but may require a longer cover garment to conceal effectively.
• IWB (Inside the Waistband) Holsters: Although primarily designed for inside-the-waistband carry, some IWB styles can be considered external depending on how they are worn. They provide a high level of concealment as they are hidden beneath clothing, but they may be less accessible than OWB options and can be uncomfortable for some users.
• Paddle Holsters: These holsters feature a paddle attachment that sits outside the waistband, allowing for easy on and off. They are often favored for their comfort and the ability to adjust the angle, but their bulk can make them slightly less concealable compared to other types.
• Belt Slide Holsters: These holsters have a simple design that slides onto the belt and is secured with belt loops or slots. They provide a low-profile option for concealed carry, but they may not offer the same level of retention as some other holster types.
• Drop Leg Holsters: Typically used by law enforcement and military personnel, these holsters attach to a belt and drop down to the thigh. They allow for quick access and comfort when seated, but they are generally not ideal for everyday concealed carry due to their visibility and bulk.
• Shoulder Holsters: These holsters are worn under the arms, distributing the weight across the shoulders. They are particularly suitable for carrying larger firearms and can be concealed under jackets or coats, but they may be less accessible for quick draws compared to belt-mounted options.
• Chest Holsters: Designed to be worn across the chest, these holsters can be a good option for outdoor activities and hiking, providing easy access and a secure fit. They may not be the best choice for everyday concealed carry due to their visibility and the need for specific clothing to conceal them effectively.

How Do OWB and IWB Holsters Differ in Functionality?

OWB (Outside the Waistband) and IWB (Inside the Waistband) holsters serve different purposes and functionalities in concealed carry.

• OWB Holsters: These holsters are worn outside the waistband, providing an accessible and comfortable option for carrying firearms.
• IWB Holsters: Designed to be worn inside the waistband, IWB holsters offer a more discreet method of concealed carry.

OWB Holsters: OWB holsters typically provide easier access to the firearm, making them a popular choice for open carry or when cover garments are worn. They often have a more comfortable fit, especially during extended wear, and can accommodate a variety of firearm sizes. However, they require more careful consideration of cover garments to ensure effective concealment.

IWB Holsters: IWB holsters are favored for their ability to keep the firearm hidden from view, making them ideal for concealed carry in various situations. They fit snugly against the body, which can enhance concealment but may require a larger belt to support the weight. Comfort can vary based on the design and the individual’s body type, but many find them to be a secure option for daily carry.

What Materials Are Commonly Used in External Holsters, and How Do They Affect Performance?

Common materials used in external holsters significantly influence their performance, comfort, and durability.

• Leather: Leather holsters are favored for their classic look and comfort against the skin. They tend to mold to the shape of the firearm and the wearer over time, providing a snug fit, but may require regular maintenance to prevent wear and moisture damage.
• Kydex: Kydex is a thermoplastic material known for its rigidity and durability. Holsters made from Kydex are typically lightweight, waterproof, and allow for a smooth draw, making them popular for concealed carry; however, they may not be as comfortable against the skin as leather.
• Nylon: Nylon holsters are lightweight and often come in various styles, including soft and molded designs. They are generally more affordable and can be very versatile, but they may not offer the same level of retention or protection as leather or Kydex options.
• Ballistic Nylon: A more robust version of standard nylon, ballistic nylon offers additional resistance to abrasions and tears. This material is often used in tactical holsters, providing a balance between weight, durability, and flexibility, but may lack the refined appearance of leather.
• Hybrid Materials: Hybrid holsters typically combine materials like Kydex and leather or nylon to leverage the benefits of both. They often provide the comfort of leather with the retention and durability of Kydex, making them a popular choice for concealed carry enthusiasts.

Which Brands Are Renowned for Making the Best Concealed Carry External Holsters?

Several brands are renowned for producing the best concealed carry external holsters:

• Alien Gear Holsters: Known for their innovative designs and modular systems, Alien Gear offers holsters that provide comfort and versatility for concealed carry.
• Safariland: This brand is recognized for its durable and tactical holsters that are designed for law enforcement and military use, ensuring reliability and ease of access.
• Galco: Galco is famous for its leather holsters, which combine classic craftsmanship with functional designs, providing both style and comfort for concealed carry.
• CrossBreed Holsters: They are known for their hybrid holsters that blend leather and Kydex materials, offering a balance of comfort and retention for everyday carry.
• Blackhawk: Blackhawk is a trusted name in tactical gear, providing a range of holsters that are designed for quick draw and secure carry, meeting the needs of both casual users and professionals.

Alien Gear Holsters focus on user comfort and adaptability, making their products suitable for a variety of firearm types and body shapes. Their holsters often feature adjustable retention and cant, allowing for a custom fit that enhances the concealed carry experience.

Safariland’s reputation stems from their commitment to quality and performance under pressure. Their holsters typically incorporate advanced retention systems that ensure the firearm remains secure while still allowing for a smooth and swift draw, which is essential for defensive situations.

Galco’s leather holsters are not only functional but also exude a classic aesthetic appeal. The high-quality leather used in their holsters molds to the user’s body over time, enhancing comfort while providing robust protection for the firearm.

CrossBreed Holsters has gained popularity for its innovative hybrid designs that merge the softness of leather with the durability of Kydex. This combination offers a snug fit and excellent retention while also being comfortable enough for all-day wear.

Blackhawk’s holsters are built to withstand rigorous use, making them a favorite among law enforcement and military personnel. Their designs focus on rapid accessibility and secure retention, ensuring that users can rely on their holsters in high-pressure situations.

What Customer Experiences Have Influenced the Reputation of These Brands?

The customer experiences that have influenced the reputation of brands offering the best concealed carry external holsters include quality, comfort, customer service, and product innovation.

• Quality: The materials and craftsmanship of a holster significantly impact user satisfaction. Customers often share their experiences regarding durability, weather resistance, and fit, which can enhance or damage a brand’s reputation based on their feedback.
• Comfort: Comfort is critical for concealed carry holsters, as users need to wear them for extended periods. Positive reviews highlighting ergonomic design and adjustable features can elevate a brand’s standing, while complaints about discomfort can lead to negative perceptions.
• Customer Service: Exceptional customer service can greatly influence a brand’s reputation, especially in the firearms industry where questions about safety and fit are common. Brands that provide responsive support and hassle-free return policies often garner loyalty from customers who feel valued and supported.
• Product Innovation: Brands that consistently innovate their holster designs to enhance functionality and usability tend to attract positive attention. Customer experiences with new features, such as quick-draw capabilities or modular designs, can set a brand apart from competitors and solidify its reputation as a leader in the industry.

Why Is Retention Crucial for Safety in Concealed Carry Holsters?

Retention is crucial for safety in concealed carry holsters because it ensures that the firearm remains securely in place, preventing accidental discharges or unauthorized access. A holster with proper retention features allows the user to draw their weapon quickly while maintaining control over it, reducing the risk of the gun being taken away or falling out during movement.

According to the National Institute of Justice, proper retention mechanisms in holsters can significantly reduce the incidence of firearm mishaps, as they prevent unintentional access by children or unauthorized individuals (NIJ, 2020). This emphasizes the importance of choosing a holster designed with retention capabilities, especially for concealed carry, where the firearm is often in close proximity to the body.

The underlying mechanism behind the need for retention in holsters is the balance between accessibility and security. When a firearm is carried in a holster that lacks sufficient retention, it becomes susceptible to being dislodged during daily activities or in the event of a physical confrontation. For instance, a holster with adjustable retention settings allows the user to customize the level of security based on their needs, ensuring that the firearm is both easily accessible in emergencies while remaining secured during routine movement. This dual need for security and accessibility is a critical factor in firearm safety, especially in concealed carry scenarios where the user may be in varied environments.

How Can You Test Retention in a Holster?

To effectively test retention in a holster, consider the following methods:

• Shake Test: This involves holding the holster upside down and shaking it to see if the firearm remains securely in place.
• Pull Test: In this method, you gently pull on the firearm while it is in the holster to assess how firmly it is held.
• Concealment Test: This test checks if the holster allows you to carry the firearm discreetly while ensuring that it remains secure.
• Draw Test: Practicing drawing the firearm from the holster helps determine if the retention mechanism permits a smooth and quick draw.
• Wearability Test: Wearing the holster in various positions (standing, sitting, moving) assesses comfort and retention during everyday activities.

The Shake Test evaluates whether the holster can hold the firearm securely under adverse conditions. If the firearm falls out during this test, it indicates inadequate retention for a concealed carry situation.

The Pull Test is crucial to ensure that the holster’s retention features effectively hold the firearm in place while still allowing for a quick draw. If you can easily pull the gun out without applying the proper technique, the holster may not be suitable for effective concealed carry.

The Concealment Test focuses on how well the holster conceals the firearm while ensuring it remains secure. A good holster should not only hide the firearm but also prevent it from shifting or becoming visible during normal movements.

The Draw Test is essential for assessing how quickly and easily you can access your firearm in a high-stress situation. A holster that provides a secure fit yet allows for a smooth draw is ideal for concealed carry purposes.

The Wearability Test examines how the holster performs in daily life scenarios. It’s important to ensure that the holster remains comfortable and does not compromise the retention of the firearm, especially when bending or sitting.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Choosing a Concealed Carry Holster?

When choosing a concealed carry holster, several common mistakes should be avoided to ensure safety, comfort, and accessibility.

• Choosing the Wrong Material: Selecting a holster made from inappropriate materials can lead to discomfort or durability issues. Leather, Kydex, and nylon each have distinct benefits; for instance, Kydex is known for its rigidity and retention, while leather offers a classic feel but may wear over time.
• Ignoring the Fit: A holster that doesn’t fit your firearm properly can compromise safety and accessibility. It’s crucial to ensure that the holster is specifically designed for your gun model to prevent it from shifting or falling out during movement.
• Neglecting Comfort: Comfort is essential for daily carry, and a holster that is too bulky or has an awkward design can deter you from carrying altogether. Look for options that have adjustable features or that conform to your body shape to enhance comfort during extended wear.
• Overlooking Retention Features: Retention refers to how securely your firearm is held in the holster. A holster without adequate retention features may allow your gun to come loose, while one with too much retention may hinder your ability to draw quickly; finding the right balance is crucial.
• Not Considering Accessibility: Accessibility is vital in a self-defense situation, so choosing a holster that allows for quick and easy access is important. Make sure that the holster’s design allows for a smooth draw without getting snagged on clothing or other items.
• Disregarding Concealment Needs: The primary purpose of a concealed carry holster is to keep your firearm hidden. Selecting a holster that is too large or that does not contour to your body can make it difficult to conceal effectively, drawing unwanted attention.
• Failing to Practice with the Holster: Simply purchasing a holster is not enough; you must also practice drawing and re-holstering your firearm to ensure you can do so quickly and safely when needed. Regular practice helps build muscle memory and confidence in your ability to respond in critical situations.

How Can Poor Holster Choice Affect Your Concealed Carry Experience?

Choosing the wrong holster can significantly impact your concealed carry experience in various ways:

• Comfort: A poorly designed holster can cause discomfort during daily wear, leading to irritation or pain.
• Accessibility: The wrong holster may make it difficult to draw your firearm quickly and effectively in a critical situation.
• Concealment: An inappropriate holster might not adequately conceal your firearm, increasing the risk of exposure and unwanted attention.
• Retention: A holster that does not securely hold your firearm can pose a safety risk, potentially leading to accidental discharges or loss of the weapon.
• Durability: Low-quality materials may result in a holster that wears out quickly, compromising its effectiveness over time.

Comfort is crucial for anyone carrying a concealed firearm, as a poorly designed holster can rub against the skin or dig into the body, causing distractions and discomfort throughout the day. If the holster is not suited to your body type or clothing, it can lead to a constant adjustment, detracting from your focus on safety and readiness.

Accessibility is vital for effective concealed carry; if a holster hinders your ability to draw your firearm quickly, it can create dangerous delays in emergencies. The mechanism of the holster should allow for a smooth and rapid draw while still keeping the firearm secure when not in use.

Concealment is another key factor; an inappropriate holster may not adequately hide your firearm beneath clothing, leading to printing or outright visibility. This can attract unwanted attention, making you a target rather than a discreet carrier, which is often the goal of concealed carry.

Retention refers to how securely the holster holds the firearm in place; a holster that fails to keep your weapon secure can result in accidents or theft. It is essential to choose a holster with reliable retention features that still allow for a quick draw when necessary.

Durability impacts the long-term effectiveness of a holster; materials that wear out quickly can compromise its functionality, making it less reliable over time. Investing in a high-quality holster made from durable materials can prevent frequent replacements and ensure consistent performance during your concealed carry experience.

Related Post:

• Best pistol hip holster
• Best pistol for bra holster
• Best pistol magazine holster
• Best pistol chest holster
• Best pistol ankle holster